TraderLog vs TradesViz: Which Trading Journal Wins?
Both platforms help you look at your trading honestly, from different angles. TraderLog imports from Schwab and IBKR and gives you a fixed set of views: calendar, stats, habit findings, replay chart. TradesViz focuses on custom charting and flexible manual entry. This comparison shows which one fits your workflow.
Feature comparison
| Feature | TraderLog | TradesViz |
|---|---|---|
| Broker Integration & Auto Import | Schwab through its API, IBKR through a Flex query, CSV for either. Fills, dates and commissions come across without typing.✓ | Requires manual trade entry or CSV uploads. Supports integration with some brokers but lacks automatic syncing. Offers flexibility but demands more time investment from users. |
| AI-Powered Performance Analysis | No machine learning is involved. Habit findings are statistics over your executions and stay silent when the sample is too thin. | Provides static dashboards and basic performance metrics. Users manually analyze charts and data. Lacks predictive intelligence or pattern recognition capabilities. |
| Trade Quality Scoring | Trades are not graded. The stats page reports win rate, profit factor, expectancy, max drawdown, streaks and results per symbol. | No automated quality assessment system. Users must manually evaluate trade quality. Limited tools for separating good trades from lucky ones. |
| Customizable Dashboards & Charts | Fixed views: a calendar, a stats page and a replay chart. Nothing to build, and nothing you can rearrange. | Highly customizable charting and dashboard layouts. Users can build exactly what they want. Superior flexibility for traders who want granular control over visualizations.✓ |
| Manual Entry & Trade Logging | Trades come from the Schwab or IBKR import, or from a CSV file. Options and stocks both land on the calendar and stats page. | Excel-like entry interface for all trade types. Flexible manual logging across crypto, forex, stocks, and options. Superior for traders preferring to manually log every trade.✓ |
| Mobile App Experience | A browser is all you need, phone included, but there is no native app to install. | Dedicated mobile app with full functionality. Traders can log and review trades from their phone seamlessly. Better user experience for mobile-first traders.✓ |
| Learning & Coaching Tools | Habit findings and the five-item pre-open checklist. Plus free calculators and a glossary on the site, and the daily Morning Map. | Educational resources and community feedback system. Users can share trades for peer review. Limited AI-driven coaching or personalized improvement recommendations. |
| Pricing & Transparency | The journal costs $60 a year and starts with 14 free days, no card. Trade with AI is $25 a month.✓ | Competitive pricing with multiple plan levels. Freemium option available for basic tracking. Some users report good value but limited features in free tier. |
| Data Security & Privacy | Fills arrive over Schwab's API connection and an IBKR Flex query. Your broker password is never entered into TraderLog. | Secure data storage with standard encryption protocols. Privacy-conscious approach to trade data. User data protection comparable to industry standards. |
| Community & Support | Email support and regular updates. There is no forum, and no way to see or discuss other traders' trades. | Established community with active forums and user discussions. Long track record of customer support. Larger user base means more peer learning opportunities available.✓ |
- ✓Schwab and IBKR imports keep the journal current without a weekly export routine.
- ✓Expectancy, profit factor, max drawdown and results per symbol are there without setting up a single chart.
- ✓Habit findings name the expensive habits: give-backs, losers held longer than winners, size jumping after a loss.
- ✓The Morning Map and the site calculators are free, so you can try the thinking before paying for anything.
- ✓Highly customizable dashboards let you design exactly what you want to see. Build personalized analytics views that match your trading methodology perfectly.
- ✓Superior manual entry interface with spreadsheet-like flexibility. Supports all asset classes and complex multi-leg trades with ease.
- ✓Dedicated mobile app provides full functionality on your phone. Trade logging and analysis work smoothly on any device.
- ✓Established community with thousands of active users sharing strategies. Peer review and feedback help traders learn from experienced community members.
Overall
TraderLog and TradesViz answer different questions. TraderLog imports your fills and shows a fixed set of views: the calendar, the stats page, habit findings and a replay chart. TradesViz gives you the tools to build whatever view you want.
If you enjoy building dashboards, TraderLog will feel narrow. If you want the answer without the assembly, the fixed views are the point.
Best for TraderLog
TraderLog suits Schwab and IBKR traders who want a complete record with no data entry. Stock and options fills both come across, and the calendar shows the day's result next to FOMC, OPEX and earnings.
It also suits traders who review by day. The daily entry, the five-item checklist and its adherence score all sit on the calendar together.
Best for TradesViz
TradesViz is the better choice if you want control over charts and metrics, or if you trade instruments TraderLog does not import automatically. Manual entry across crypto and forex is its strength.
It also has a mobile app and a larger community. TraderLog has neither, and it does not label or grade individual trades.
The bottom line
Both beat a spreadsheet. TraderLog gets you accurate history and a working stats page in an afternoon. TradesViz gives you flexibility if you are willing to configure it.
Start with TraderLog if your broker is Schwab or IBKR and you want fewer decisions. Start with TradesViz if custom views and a mobile app are the reason you are shopping.
Frequently asked questions
TraderLog's automatic import works best with Schwab and IBKR accounts. You can still use manual entry for other brokers, crypto exchanges, or forex platforms. The experience isn't as seamless, but AI analysis still works on manually entered trades. Contact TraderLog about planned integrations for your broker.
TradesViz focuses on manual analytics and customizable dashboards rather than AI-powered insights. You analyze your own data using charts and metrics provided. Some traders prefer this hands-on approach, while others want machine learning doing the analysis. The platforms take fundamentally different philosophical approaches to performance analysis.
TraderLog is the budget-friendly option: $60/year for the journal, $25/month for the full AI plan, each with a free trial. TraderLog's plans are $60/year for the journal and $25/month for Trade with AI, each with a free trial. TradesViz includes a freemium option with limited features and paid upgrades. Your specific needs determine which offers better long-term value for your situation.
Both platforms support data export to ensure you retain your trading records. TraderLog allows exporting trade data and reports in standard formats. TradesViz provides comprehensive export options maintaining all your custom analytics. Always verify current export capabilities as features evolve regularly.
TraderLog's AI Coach and behavioral analysis accelerate improvement by identifying specific patterns. Machine learning reveals what actually works versus what you think works. TradesViz requires you to manually analyze data but supports this with flexible charting tools. AI-driven coaching typically produces faster improvements for most traders.
See your own numbers in TraderLog first
Import from Schwab or IBKR and the calendar, stats page and habit findings fill in from your fills. Nothing to configure, and no card for the 14-day trial. If you would rather bring a file, CSV works for both brokers.